At the beginning of the film, the idea is voiced that 100 years ago everything was the same as it is now. The events are transferred to 1914, we see a ball and a young couple, during the dialogue of which it turns out that the girl is a heart surgeon. I don't want to watch anymore. The authors at least tried to study the history of
more
At the beginning of the film, the idea is voiced that 100 years ago everything was the same as it is now. The events are transferred to 1914, we see a ball and a young couple, during the dialogue of which it turns out that the girl is a heart surgeon. I don't want to watch anymore. The authors at least tried to study the history of women doctors in Russia. The fact is that things were extremely bad with this (at one time I read the story of the first female doctor Nadezhda Suslova). First, women were not allowed to pursue higher education. 3-4 women were recruited to attend the courses of the professor, the diploma was not given at the end of the courses (the girls completed their studies in Lausanne, Switzerland (mainly). Second, even when they were educated, they were not hired in clinics, some were allowed to open private offices (you can imagine how much money their parents should have for their European education and their own practice). Third, under such circumstances, no one would trust surgery (especially cardiac surgery). The first female surgeon of the Russian Empire, Vera Giedroyc, graduated at the age of 28, began to practice surgery at home at the age of 34 as a field surgeon during the Russian-Japanese War, again I note - not a heart surgeon (plus in the film we show a young girl). And most importantly: clinical cardiac surgery, or "cardiac surgery", began in 1938 (in the United States) and in 1948 (in Russia) with surgery for the ungrown arterial duct, and was born in the 1940-1950s in parallel with the formation of clinical cardiology. What operations could have been carried out in 1914? And yes, the first Russian woman cardiac surgeon was Elena Sidorenko (the first operation in 1962, the woman was 37 years old - not a girl again). I understand that this is a comedy, not an autobiography (other Christmas trees also had blunders, for example, heterosexual patients in traumatology were put on adjacent beds), but when the film begins with outright nonsense, it is sad. P.S. Fast forward and realized that the girl was the daughter of the king, who in the real 1914 was 17. Apparently, she lied (which doctor at 17?), which does not negate the fact that the concept of cardiac surgery did not exist. And the king with a Georgian accent? It doesn't even look rewindable.
|